Twist type 'garden claw' good for weeds?

[Mamzie]

Tool I used most during years was my Bampis old matthock, which somehow was lost when I went quite ill 10 years ago Tool I use most now is a mini hand mattock with a rake type claw on other side. My husband loves his fork and spade. I think I bought him one of these 15 or so years ago and it was sold on car boot few years later, virtually unused x

[rary]

I was using one today,but don't have a lot of weeds in the garden any that I did have were easy to remove after going over the ground with the claw I note that some folk don't like it but I find it quite good for loosening the soil without digging

[DWSmith]

https://www.homebase.co.uk/fiskars-x...puller_p178414

Similar to one of those snoop?

I tend to just use my hori hori (does most things for me to be fair) and a fork.

Jimny14, Fiskars replaced their garden claw with this. That explains why I couldn't find Fiskars version of the claw. I found one of these in the shed a few days ago. Turns out SWMBO bought one and uses it for weeks in the lawn. I'll have to see how it does in the vegetable bed.