Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Apple Scab - Leaf Damage Assesment.

Collapse

X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Apple Scab - Leaf Damage Assesment.

    Having been a bad year for scab (despite me living in one of the drier parts of the UK), I decided to study and document the extent of scab on my apples.
    None of my varieties escaped scab entirely, but many showed strong resistance to damage. I have never sprayed them with chemicals, so any disease prevalence is completely natural.
    My varieties were chosen to suit dry areas, where powdery mildew is a big problem - so they have good levels of natural resistance to powdery mildew, with scab as the second priority and no regard for canker resistance.

    Several distinct types of scab attack were noticeable:

    1. Pinpoint specks about 1mm across.
    Typically 5% of total leaf area killed.


    2. Medium sized blotches about 1-3 mm across.
    Typically 10% of total leaf area killed.


    3. Large lesions several mm across which leave tattered holes in the leaves.
    Typically 15-20% of total leaf area killed.


    4. Large lesions several mm across which merge together and kill the leaf.
    Typically 25-30% of total leaf area killed.

    Generally, the total amount of leaf area destroyed is proportional to the type of scab observed.


    The following is my estimate of scab damage to the leaves (not fruits) on my plants - scored between 1-4, as per the above generalised categories. A score of 0 would have been reserved for varieties with no scab.
    The fruits of russets tend to be more scab resistant than the leaves.

    In alphabet order......

    Annie Elizabeth: 1
    Ashmead's Kernel (russet): 1
    Bramley 20: 2
    Court Pendu Plat: 2
    Crawley Beauty: 1
    D'Arcy Spice (russet): 3
    Discovery: 1
    Egremont Russet (russet): 2
    Ellison's Orange: 1
    Fiesta: 2
    Golden Delicious: 3
    Grenadier: 1
    Howgate Wonder: 2
    James Grieve: 1
    Liberty: 1
    Meridian: 3
    Pinova: 3
    Reverend Wilks: 2
    Saturn: 4
    Spartan: 3
    Tydeman's Late Orange: 1
    Winston: 2
    Winter Gem: 2
    Worcester Pearmain: 1

    I hope that's of interest, but please don't base a major planting decision entirely on my findings!

    FB.
    .

  • #2
    24 trees,lucky you,my Howgate and J.Grieve got the scab quite badly,the books say to spray next year,but I'm not happy using chemicals,do I have a choice(other than scabby apples)

    Comment


    • #3
      Mine are mainly a mixture of bushes and cordons - only a few are half-standards. I have a few more than listed because some are doubles - I have Annie Elizabeth as MM106/hstd and M26/cordon. Likewise with a few others.

      The local crab apples here are heavily scabbed this year - far worse than any of my apples. Some of the local crabs are almost completely stripped of leaves.

      To try to reduce scab next year, you could rake up and burn the fallen leaves.

      But if it's a dry year next year, the scab may not be too problematic.
      .

      Comment


      • #4
        Thanks for that FB,shalln't hold my breath for a dry summer though.

        Comment


        • #5
          The leaves are now falling, so here's an estimate of final scab leaf damage. I can't compare fruit damage because the early and mid-season fruits have been eaten already.

          Scoring system:
          1. Pinpoint specks about 1mm across.
          Typically 5% of total leaf area killed.

          2. Medium sized blotches about 1-3 mm across.
          Typically 10% of total leaf area killed.

          3. Large lesions several mm across which leave tattered holes in the leaves.
          Typically 15-20% of total leaf area killed.

          4. Large lesions several mm across which merge together and kill the leaf.
          Typically 25-30% of total leaf area killed.



          Annie Elizabeth: 3
          Ashmead's Kernel (russet): 2 (fruit damage: 1)
          Bramley 20: 2
          Court Pendu Plat: 2 (fruit damage: 1)
          Crawley Beauty: 1
          D'Arcy Spice (russet): 3 (fruit damage: 1)
          Discovery: 2
          Egremont Russet (russet): 2 (fruit damage: 1)
          Ellison's Orange: 3
          Fiesta: 4
          Golden Delicious: 3
          Grenadier: 1
          Howgate Wonder: 2
          James Grieve: 2
          Liberty: 3
          Meridian: 3
          Pinova: 3
          Reverend Wilks: 4
          Saturn: 4
          Spartan: 3
          Tydeman's Late Orange: 2
          Winston: 2
          Winter Gem: 2
          Worcester Pearmain: 2
          Last edited by FB.; 10-11-2008, 01:07 PM. Reason: typo's
          .

          Comment

          Latest Topics

          Collapse

          Recent Blog Posts

          Collapse
          Working...
          X